Casting Begins for Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2’s Next Hallmark Hunk

The search is on for a new batch of kind-hearted hunks to compete in season 2 of *Finding Mr. Christmas*. The hit reality competition is hosted and co-created by longtime Hallmark Channel star Jonathan Bennett. Critics and fans fell in love with the 10 men who competed in the original Hallmark+ series over the 2024 holiday season, as well as Bennett and his co-host, actress Melissa Peterman.

So much so that Hallmark Media announced on December 23 that it had greenlit a second season. With filming set to begin in April 2025, production company Super Delicious has begun looking for a new group of men eager to compete for *a featured role in a Hallmark movie*, per casting call materials.

Season 2 Casting Call: What They’re Looking For

Finding the next Hallmark hunk is no small task. According to the casting call for season 2 of *Finding Mr. Christmas*, the production team is looking for aspiring actors, ages 25-42 with *charming good looks and a twinkle in your eye*.

A lengthy application asks potential contestants about their backgrounds, families, acting experience, social media profiles, and in-depth questions about their lives. Applicants are also asked to upload a headshot, full body photo, and a video introducing themselves.

Key Qualities of a Hallmark Star

Given the show’s theme, the application also asks applicants to share a favorite holiday memory and explain how they typically celebrate the holidays. *All of our leading men have charisma, they have a sense of humor, they have a sense of wit. They have charm coming out of their ears. They’re nice, they’re kind, they’re good people,* said Bennett.

He continued, *They have a huge heart and, at the end of the day, they look amazing in Christmas sweaters. They have great teeth and perfect hair and look good in a Christmas sweater. Those were the things we were looking for as our baseline, but then all of these guys brought so much more than we could have ever hoped for.*

Season 1 Recap: What Made It a Hit

The first season’s winner — model Ezra Moreland — won over the judges, including a different Hallmark star who guest judged each episode, from Nikki DeLoach to Tyler Hynes. As his prize, he got to co-star with Jessica Lowndes in Hallmark Channel’s last Christmas movie of 2024, *Happy Howlidays*.

During the competition, Moreland realized it wasn’t just about having chiseled abs or a winning smile. In one challenge, the men had to get emotional in a test scene with longtime Hallmark star Rachel Boston, which was not an easy take, he told *Us Weekly*.

The Emotional Roller Coaster

*That (challenge) was the scariest because we realized, ‘Oh we’re going to be judged on emotional availability,’ and that was freaky and stressful at first,* he told the outlet. *But looking back, that’s one of my favorite (moments) because it was the biggest roller coaster, and kind of nerve-wracking.*

After winning the first season, Moreland began two months of acting lessons, he told *Entertainment Weekly*, and spent time getting to know Lowndes before they began filming in September.

What to Expect in Season 2

The anticipation for season 2 of *Finding Mr. Christmas* is palpable. With the bar set high by the first season, the production team is undoubtedly looking to elevate the competition. The casting process itself is rigorous, ensuring that only the most charismatic and genuine individuals make it to the screen.

This season promises to delve deeper into the personal stories and emotional journeys of the contestants, making for compelling viewing.

Challenges and Surprises

Fans can expect a variety of challenges designed to test the contestants’ acting skills, emotional depth, and ability to connect with an audience. From heartwarming holiday-themed tasks to intense acting scenes, the competition will push the men to their limits. And of course, there will be plenty of surprises along the way, including special guest appearances by beloved Hallmark stars.

How to Apply

If you think you have what it takes to be the next Hallmark hunk, now is your chance. The application process is detailed and thorough, but it’s designed to find the best of the best. Here’s what you need to know:

• Age Requirement: Applicants must be between 25-42 years old.
• Application Details: Be prepared to share your background, family details, acting experience, social media profiles, and answer in-depth questions about your life.
• Photos and Videos: You will need to upload a headshot, full body photo, and a video introduction.
• Holiday Memories: Share a favorite holiday memory and describe how you celebrate the holidays.
• Availability: Contestants must be available for filming in April and May 2025 and be able to travel to various locations.

Tips for a Successful Application

Here are some tips to help you stand out in your application:

• Be Genuine: Authenticity is key. Share your true self and personal stories.
• Show Your Charisma: Highlight your sense of humor, wit, and charm.
• Emphasize Kindness: Hallmark stars are known for their big hearts and kindness.
• Look the Part: Make sure your photos and video show you at your best, especially in a Christmas sweater!

Conclusion

Season 2 of *Finding Mr. Christmas* promises to be even more exciting and heartwarming than the first.

With a new group of charismatic and kind-hearted men ready to compete, fans are in for a treat.

Whether you’re an aspiring actor looking for your big break or a fan eagerly awaiting the next season, *Finding Mr. Christmas* is sure to deliver holiday cheer and unforgettable moments.

Stay tuned for more updates and get ready to find out who will be the next Hallmark hunk!