Top 23 Hallmark Hunks Who Make Love Stories Unforgettable
Hallmark movies have become a beloved staple in homes across the globe. They are known for their heartwarming stories, festive cheer, and of course, their dashing male leads.
These actors bring charm, talent, and a touch of small-town magic to our screens. In this post, we’ll explore some of the most notable Hallmark male actors, their backgrounds, and the roles that have made them fan favorites.
Let’s dive into the world of Hallmark’s leading men and discover what makes them so special.
Jack Wagner: A Versatile Talent
Jack Wagner is a name synonymous with Hallmark movies, but his talents extend far beyond the network. Known for his extensive resume, Wagner is not only an accomplished actor but also a musician and golfer.
His significant TV roles include *Santa Barbara*, *Melrose Place*, *General Hospital*, and *The Bold and the Beautiful*. On Hallmark, he shines as investigator Bill Avery in *When Calls the Heart*.
An interesting fact about Wagner is that he appeared in over 1,300 episodes of *The Bold and the Beautiful*.
Benjamin Ayres: From Sci-Fi to Romance
Before joining Hallmark, Benjamin Ayres made his mark on shows like *Battlestar Galactica*, *Supernatural*, *Reunion*, *Killer Instinct*, and *Smallville*.
His Hallmark debut came in 2016’s *Love by Chance*, and since then, he has starred in beloved films such as *Falling for Vermont* (2017), *You, Me & the Christmas Trees* (2021), *Long Lost Christmas* (2022), and *The Santa Class* (2024).
Colin Lawrence: A Rising Star
English-Canadian actor Colin Lawrence has been steadily rising in popularity with his roles in television series like *The Killing*, *iZombie*, *Impastor*, and *Riverdale*. Currently, he plays Preacher on Netflix’s hit series *Virgin River*.
Lawrence is a more recent addition to the Hallmark scene, with appearances in *Morning Show Mysteries: Murder Ever After* (2021) and *Napa Ever After* (2023).
Peter Mooney: A New Face to Watch
Canadian actor Peter Mooney recently starred in Hallmark’s *Retreat to You* (2023) and made his debut in *Fly Away With Me* (2022). Outside of Hallmark, Mooney is known for his roles in *Rookie Blue*, *Camelot*, *The Prodigy*, and *We Were Wolves*.
Keep an eye out for his future projects!
Ronnie Rowe, Jr.: From Sci-Fi to Hallmark
Ronnie Rowe, Jr. initially became interested in acting as a child and found his way back to the craft as he grew older. He has appeared in series like *Star Trek: Discovery*, *Dual Suspects*, *The Firm*, and *Warehouse 13*.
On Hallmark, you can catch him in *Jingle Bell Bride* (2020), *Inventing the Christmas Prince* (2022), and *Christmas With a Kiss* (2023).
Kavan Smith: A Fan Favorite
Kavan Smith is beloved for his role as Leland Coulter in *When Calls the Heart*. His career includes roles in *Smallville*, *Supernatural*, *Battlestar Galactica*, and *The Outer Limits*.
Other notable Hallmark works include *Big Sky River* (2022), *Big Sky River: The Bridal Path* (2023), and *Love on the Menu* (2019).
Corey Sevier: A Versatile Performer
Corey Sevier has a long and impressive resume, with guest roles in shows like *Psych*, *CSI: Miami*, *Smallville*, *Supernatural*, and *Murdoch Mysteries*.
His Hallmark films include *Take Me Back for Christmas* (2023), *Pumpkin Everything* (2022), *Road Trip Romance* (2022), *The Dog Lover’s Guide to Dating* (2023), *Noel Next Door* (2022), and *Heart of the Holidays* (2020).
Brennan Elliott: A Hallmark Staple
Brennan Elliott made his television debut as Dr. Nick Biancavilla in *Strong Medicine*. His Hallmark career includes appearances in the *Cedar Cove* series, *A Christmas Melody* (2015), *Love You Like Christmas* (2016), *The Perfect Pairing* (2022), and *His and Hers* (2024).
Wes Brown: A Longtime Hallmark Star
Texas native Wes Brown started his acting career in 2004 and is known for his role in HBO’s *True Blood*. His Hallmark debut came in 2011’s *Love’s Everlasting Courage*.
Recent films include *Every Time a Bell Rings* (2021), *Under the Autumn Moon* (2018), *Over the Moon in Love* (2019), and *Deck the Walls* (2024).
Niall Matter: A Journey to Acting
Niall Matter’s path to acting began after a traumatic accident on an oil rig. He has since appeared in *The Best Years*, *Stargate Atlantis*, and *Eureka*.
His Hallmark films include the *Aurora Teagarden Mysteries* series, *Holiday Hotline* (2023), and *This Time Each Year* (2024).
Stephen Huszar: Leading Man Energy
Stephen Huszar began his Hallmark career almost a decade ago with the *Aurora Teagarden Mysteries* films. His most recent film, *Everything Puppies* (2024), is a special one, especially since he often films alongside his sweetheart, Katie Cassidy.
Marcus Rosner: From Athlete to Actor
Marcus Rosner made his Hallmark debut in 2014’s *Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters*. His recent film, *Falling Like Snowflakes* (2024), is just one of many beloved titles.
He has also appeared in *Yes, I Do* (2018), *Love On Harbor Island* (2020), *Romance to the Rescue* (2022), and *Notes of Autumn* (2023).
Luke Macfarlane: A Hallmark Favorite
Luke Macfarlane’s first Hallmark role was in 2014’s *The Memory Book*. Other notable films include *Christmas Land* (2015), *The Mistletoe Promise* (2016), *The Birthday Wish* (2017), and *A Shoe Addicts Christmas* (2018).
His latest role is in *CrimeTime: Freefall* (2023), with *Home Is Where the Heart Is* coming soon on Hallmark+.
Ian Harding: From Teen Drama to Hallmark
Ian Harding, known for his role as Ezra Fitz on *Pretty Little Liars*, made his Hallmark debut in 2022’s *Ghosts of Christmas Always*. He starred in the Hallmark+ series *Holidazed* and will soon appear in the new series *Ripple* in 2025.
Chris McNally: A Hearties Favorite
Chris McNally is known for his role as Lucas Bouchard in *When Calls the Heart*. Other Hallmark works include *The Sweetest Heart* (2018), *Rocky Mountain Christmas* (2017), and *Hearts of Christmas* (2016).
McNally appreciates the dedicated fanbase of *When Calls the Heart*, known as the Hearties.
Paul Campbell: A British Charm
Paul Campbell, who got his start in *Battlestar Galactica*, has appeared in *Days of Our Lives*, *How I Met Your Mother*, *Scrubs*, and *Knight Rider*.
His Hallmark films include *Three Wise Men and a Baby* (2022) and its sequel, *Christmas by Starlight* (2020).
Will Kemp: From Stage to Screen
Will Kemp began his career as a dancer before transitioning to acting. His early roles include *The Great Fire*, *Reign*, *Girlfriends’ Guide to Divorce*, and *Spinning Out*.
His Hallmark films include *Royal Matchmaker* (2018), *Love, Romance & Chocolate* (2019), *Christmas Waltz* (2020), and *Jolly Good Christmas* (2022).
Kristoffer Polaha: A Hallmark Veteran
Kristoffer Polaha is one of the most famous faces on Hallmark. Since starring alongside Meghan Markle in 2016’s *Dater’s Handbook*, he has appeared in *The Christmas Quest* (2024) and *A Biltmore Christmas* (2023).
Polaha values his work with Hallmark for the opportunities to collaborate and improve scripts.
Tyler Hynes: A Hallmark Family
Tyler Hynes started on Hallmark in 2018 with *Falling for You*. His notable films include *Flip That Romance* (2019), *My Boyfriend’s Back: Wedding March 5* (2019), *The Mistletoe Secret* (2019), *Winter in Vail* (2020), and *A Picture of Her* (2023).
His latest film is *Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story* (2024).
Kevin McGarry: A Versatile Actor
Kevin McGarry is known for his role as Nathan Grant in *When Calls the Heart*. He has also appeared in *Heartland*, *Winter Love Story* (2019), *Winter Castle* (2019), and *My Grown-Up Christmas List* (2022).
McGarry is known for his humor and charm, making him a fan favorite.
Brant Daugherty: From Teen Drama to Hallmark
Brant Daugherty, known for his role as Noel Kahn on *Pretty Little Liars*, made his Hallmark debut in 2018 with *Mingle All the Way*.
His recent film, *Trivia at St. Nick’s*, is part of Hallmark’s 2024 Countdown to Christmas. Daugherty continues to impress with his performances.
Andrew Walker: Hallmark Royalty
Andrew Walker has appeared in more than 20 Hallmark films, making him a dedicated actor on the network. One of his most popular titles is *Three Wise Men and a Baby* (2022), and he reprised his role in the sequel.
Walker is also an entrepreneur, co-owning a juice company called Little West with his wife Cassandra.
Ryan Paevey: A Beloved Leading Man
Ryan Paevey started his acting career in music videos. He gained fame with his role as Nathan West on *General Hospital*.
His Hallmark debut came in 2016 with *Unleashing Mr. Darcy*. Since then, Paevey has starred in *Harvest Love* (2017), *Hope at Christmas* (2018), *From Friend to Fiancé* (2019), *A Summer Romance* (2019), and *Two Tickets to Paradise* (2022).
Although he is stepping away from acting for some time, Paevey remains a beloved Hallmark actor.
These Hallmark male actors bring a unique blend of talent, charm, and heart to the screen, making them fan favorites. Whether they are seasoned veterans or rising stars, their contributions to Hallmark films continue to captivate audiences and spread joy year-round.
